The
Borg Warner Overdrive Transmission began its life in the
1930s and was last used anywhere in the automotive industry
in Ford trucks in 1972. Overdrive was last used in Ford passenger
cars in 1967.
This
article is to explain this unique transmission and its
features to Ford truck owners & enthusiasts in the hopes
that they will have a better understanding of how fortunate
they are to have acquired one and better understand how to
operate, repair, and enjoy it.
Popularity of the B-W OD lessened over its long production
life, especially after availability of fully automatic
transmissions, but it still remains the most versatile
transmission ever put into a vehicle. However, to maximize
its full operating potential, the driver must understand
what it does and how it works. Unfortunately the chances of
a 21st-century truck buyer who might be lucky enough to come
across an overdrive-equipped Ford truck appreciating how
lucky a find they have diminishes every year. It then
becomes ever more likely that the marvelous overdrive set up
would be removed and the truck converted to another
transmission type...a sad loss indeed.
There
are many ways to “overdrive” a vehicle. To overdrive
something is to gear it in such a manner that more
revolutions come out of a gear set (the transmission) than
went into it. Overdriving a running gear (motor,
transmission & axle combination) lowers the revolutions that
the engine spins at any set speed, but overdriving also
exchanges this lower engine speed for less of a mechanical
advantage - less able to pull away from a stop, the less
able to pull a load, the less able to pull a hill. In the
simplest terms, overdrive acts like a super-high gear that
is intended to be used only at freeway speeds to lower the
engine revolutions, lower engine wear and lower both engine
oil and fuel consumption.
Overdriving a vehicle can be done in many ways, such as
adding an additional entire transmission (like a Brownie
auxiliary transmission) or adding an additional ‘gear’ to
the existing transmission (like modern five-speed
transmissions, where 5th gear is overdrive). An overdrive
ratio can also be created with a planetary gear set. (This
is how a Borg-Warner OD transmission accomplishes an
overdrive ratio).
A
planetary gear set is what exists in most automatic
transmissions. You can read elsewhere about how the holding
and releasing of the sun, planet and ring gears give various
ratios, but for the purpose of understanding how a B-W OD
system works all that needs to be remembered is that when
the sun gear is held and the planets are driven by the
transmission the output shaft, then more revolutions are
sent to the driveshaft than went into the transmission.
Holding and releasing the sun gear is all it takes to make a
B-W OD transmission go into and out of overdrive.
History and operation of the
Borg-Warner Overdrive Transmission
The B-W
OD transmission originated during the 1930s to solve a
number of problems that existed on cars at that time. It
uses a freewheeling clutch that began life in the 1920s and
later added a planetary gear set (operated as a purely
mechanical device in the early 30s) and eventually finalized
the design by using electrical components to operate the
system by the late 1930s. Most every automotive manufacture
offered the B-W OD set up as an option on their cars at one
time during their production life.
Manufacturers who focused their marketing toward operating
economy were all heavy promoters of the B-W overdrive.
Studebaker probably made more OD-equipped vehicles than
anybody. Other AMC marques (Hudson, Rambler, Nash) were also
big users. Ford first offered the Borg-Warner OD on Lincoln
Zephyrs beginning in 1941. Fords and Mercurys received the
B-W OD as an option in 1949 and the F-series trucks got OD
for 1953. (Before 1941 & 1949 Ford, Lincoln & Mercury used a
two speed axle to lower engine revolutions – The Columbia
axle - not discussed here).
To
understand the B-W OD, the features it has and how to
properly drive it, one needs to understand the driving
conditions that existed during the 1930s & 40s. At that time
all vehicles were operated by a low horsepower (80-100HP)
low compression engine, with a very long stroke (4+ inches
would not be unusual). This engine design is very
appropriate for in town driving conditions. (start & stop,
no hills and speeds that do not exceed 40 mph).
To make
it possible for a low power 1930s-40s engine to climb hills
and haul loads manufactures installed very low rear axle
ratios. (High numerically) 4:10+ was common and some
vehicles approached and sometimes exceeded a 5:1 ratio.
These ratios made it possible to climb a hill (road building
technology was equally behind 21st century techniques,
grades were steeper back then) but would also spin an engine
very fast at highway speeds. (60 mph was exceptionally fast
in 1940!) Overdrive transmissions made modern freeway speeds
possible while saving gas, oil and engines. (Thrown rods
were common in the 1930s & 40s).
A
Borg-Warner OD has sometimes been called a ‘cable-operated’
overdrive...IT IS NOT! A B-W OD is electrically operated.
The only control visible to the driver is a cable located
somewhere on the dashboard. However all this cable does is
‘lock out’ the entire system. When the knob/cable is pulled
out the transmission operates entirely as a standard
three-speed transmission. With a properly-operating system
and knowledgeable driver, the cable will be pushed in 90% of
the time. When the OD cable IS pushed in, the first
operating feature of the B-W OD transmission becomes
apparent it “freewheels”. This means that while the engine
can drive the wheels, when the vehicle coasts, no power is
fed back to the engine. No engine braking, just coasting.
When
the electrical components of a B-W OD are not functioning
this is all that the transmission will do - freewheel.
Freewheeling at speed is dangerous and can lead to loss of
control due to increased brake use. However a properly
functioning B-W OD does NOT freewheel at speeds above 28
mph. In a properly functioning OD engine braking DOES
happen. The thought that engine braking is not possible is a
major misconception for a B-W OD transmission.
The
other operating control for a B-W OD transmission is not
readily visible to the driver (and not visible at all from
the driver’s seat of a 67-72 Ford truck) it is the kick down
switch. The kick down switch is a push button type switch
that is operated only when the accelerator is fully
depressed (mashed to the floor) Before 1967, Ford trucks
used a switch design that goes all the way back to the
1930s. It protruded through a hole in the floor and was
activated by the back of the gas pedal. Starting in 1967
(1963 for cars) the kick down switch migrated to the
firewall and was operated by the throttle linkage.
Driving with overdrive
Driving
a B-W OD vehicle starts off with the cable pushed in and the
truck pulling away in first gear as normal. The truck
accelerates and the driver shifts into second gear. At
approximately 28 mph (BTW - nobody knows why 28 mph and not
25 or 30 mph) a small click can sometimes be heard from
under the hood (activation of the relay on the firewall by
the governor on the transmission) the driver then backs off
on the gas and the transmission automatically shifts into
overdrive. The shift feels exactly like a shift from an
automatic transmission.
The
driver must release the accelerator completely such that the
power comes back from the wheels toward the engine to
complete the shift to OD. In an automatic transmission a
shift will occur (eventually) even if the throttle is held
open. For mechanical design reasons in a B-W OD set up, the
driver MUST let off the throttle completely to allow the
shift to happen.
With
the vehicle in second gear overdrive, the overall ratio is
not quite as high as third, but higher than second. This is
a perfect ratio for in town use. Between stoplights you
don’t need to shift into third. However, if you continue
accelerating and shift into third (from 2nd OD) and you will
then be in third gear overdrive, the perfect ratio for the
highway.
An
often asked question is “Can you overdrive first gear?” The
answer is yes, however you would have to exceed 28 mph for
the system to activate. The real question then becomes ‘Can
you exceed 28 mph in first?’ 28 mph is pretty fast for first
gear so 1st gear OD is rarely achieved. This means that
while a B-W OD transmission has sometimes been called a ‘6
speed’ it is really provides only 5 practical forward
ratios.
While
you are in overdrive if you back off the gas you will feel
engine braking. (second or third) Because it is an overdrive
ratio, the braking is not as evident as if the transmission
were in 2nd or 3rd direct drive but the transmission does
NOT coast. If the transmission does coast, the OD set up is
not operating properly.
Third
gear OD is great for gliding along at highway speeds but it
can lack power for passing or hill climbing. To get the
transmission out of overdrive, mash the gas pedal to the
floor. The engine will rev up and when the pedal compresses
the kick down switch, it will suddenly and quickly shift
back into direct drive. This shift feels exactly like the
kick down of an automatic transmission. Complete your pass
or top the hill in direct gear, then let off the gas
completely for a moment and the transmission will shift back
into overdrive.
If you
begin slowing down and shift from third OD to second OD,
then slow down further as if approaching a stop light, as
soon as the speed falls below 28 mph the power to the OD
will be cut and the transmission will then be back in direct
drive.
This
automatic loss of OD is a designed in safety feature because
you must start out from a complete stop only in direct
drive. To try to start out from a standing start in
overdrive would create an incredible strain on the driveline
is certain to damage something or at least result in
increased clutch wear.
Owners
have sometimes rewired their systems and by-passed the
governor by adding a manual switch to turn the system on &
off. If this has been done it is very easy to forget and
attempt to take off from a stop in first gear-overdrive.
Doing this is as fool hardy as by-passing the neutral safety
switch on an automatic transmission.
So as you slow down below 28 mph you are automatically put
back into second gear direct drive. HOWEVER, because the sun
gear is no longer being held (no OD ratio) the transmission
will freewheel. This event can be very surprising to someone
who is not familiar with the operation of an OD transmission
as suddenly there is NO engine braking! Since this occurs
only below 28 mph there should not be much need for engine
braking and using the foot brake to stop the truck should be
just fine.
But
this is also where another novel aspect driving with a B-W
OD transmission becomes apparent. All B-W OD transmission
set ups (from all manufactures in all years) used a
non-synchronized first gear. They never built a B-W OD
transmission with a synchronized first gear.
By the
1960s full syncro transmissions were fully available, so why
didn’t they make a fully synchronized OD? Turns out a B-W OD
trans doesn’t need to be synchronized!
Drive
in second gear OD, slow down below 28 mph and the trans
falls out of OD and into freewheel mode. Step on the clutch
and pull the lever into first and you will find it slips
into first gear as easily as if it were synchronized! Even
if you are rolling.
This
‘synchro effect’ happens because the freewheeling clutch
prevents power from being transmitted from the driveshaft
into the transmission. Push in the clutch and there are NO
forces on the gears. When you pull the lever into first gear
it slips in easily. The most clashing you get when shifting
into first gear at a rolling speed, is a slight “ratcheting”
of the gear teeth that you would expect if you were shifting
from neutral into the low granny gear of a truck 4 speed or
the reverse gear in any transmission.
The
freewheeling feature also makes clutchless shifting
possible. Start in first, pull away and then WITHOUT
depressing the clutch pedal, back off the gas and shift into
second as easily as if you had pushed the clutch! If you
shift into third gear before 28 mph (and engaging the OD)
again there is no need to depress the clutch pedal to make
the shift. If however you have allowed the transmission to
engage the OD in second (backing of the gas) then depressing
the clutch is necessary to shift from 2nd to 3rd.
These
operational features are what made the B-W OD transmission
very desirable in the days before fully automatic
transmissions. (Especially with the ladies). No clashing
shifts into first; No clutch necessary to shift into second;
Automatic shift into second OD around town.
One
other aspect of the freewheeling clutch needs to be
discussed; parking and pushing.
Pulling
out the OD cable on the dash operates a lever on the side of
the transmission and mechanically locks the sun gear to the
planetary gears. (Ideally the cable should only be pulled
out while the vehicle is stopped).
When the OD cable is pushed in then the whole system just
freewheels. This happens as long as the vehicle is below 28
MPH (or the system has no electrical power) the OD will not
engage. This means that to push start an OD equipped truck,
the cable needs to be pulled out for the wheels to send
power to the engine when the clutch is released.
Parking
is the other situation that pulling out the OD cable is
necessary. If you park pointing downhill and put the shifter
into first, second or third without pulling out the cable,
the forward motion will freewheel over the engine and the
truck will roll away. There is no compression lock. To
overcome this you can either pull the OD cable out or place
the shifter into reverse.
In
order for any OD transmission to back up, the freewheeling
clutch MUST be locked out. There is a shaft/rod built into
the transmission that automatically accomplishes this
whenever the transmission is put into reverse. So to park
safely (set the brake) and then either pull out the OD cable
OR place the shifter into reverse. This locks up the
driveline and prevents all rolling.
Couple
the OD transmission with the very low rear end gears that
existed in the 30s & 40s and you effectively had an
automatic transmission. Owners manuals from that time
suggested that around town you could (should?) start out in
second gear slipping the clutch only slightly, (possible
with a very low rear end gearing) then letting the trans
shift itself into second overdrive. No need to touch the
lever and limited use of the clutch, what more could you ask
for?
Speaking of rear end gears how are they affected by the
overdrive? All B-W ODs overdrive function at a 0.7 overdrive
ratio. Since all transmissions use a 1:1 ratio in high gear,
to find out your final drive ratio in OD simply multiply the
rear end ratio by 0.7.
4.11 = 2.87 3.70 = 2.59
Even a very low 4.56 ratio can be tamed by an OD into a very
functional 3.19.
This is
what makes the B-W OD so appropriate for use in a truck. In
a truck a low geared rear end could help it haul a heavy
load but you don’t want to spin the engine so fast at
highway speeds or when the truck is empty. With a functional
OD you get the best of both worlds, strong low end pulling
AND practical highway and unloaded use.
An OD
can also compensate for small diameter wheels & tires.
Smaller wheels & tires spin an engine faster. 16” wheels
turn the driveline slower than 15” which spin the driveline
slower than 14” (as the wheels/tires get bigger they carry
more weight and lower the engine speed but they also reduce
the available power. All things are a compromise) All these
factors need to be considered when outfitting a vehicle with
a B-W OD transmission. If you use a rear axle ratio that is
too high (numerically low) and/or couple it with
wheels/tires that are too big in diameter a vehicle can
actually slow down or use more fuel when it is operating in
OD.
Troubleshooting
The
Borg-Warner overdrive transmission combines both mechanical
and electrical components. The mechanical components are
very stout and as long as the transmission AND THE OVERDRIVE
unit is filled with gear oil (see maintenance below) the
only problems should be electrical, which are very easy to
trouble shoot.
Take an OD truck out for a test drive with the OD cable
pushed in, if it freewheels above 28 mph (and you don’t feel
the automatic shift) the trans is OK but there is an
electrical problem.
The OD
electrical system is protected by just one fuse clipped to
the relay on the firewall. This fuse gets power whenever the
key is turned on. Begin your diagnosis by checking for power
at both sides of this fuse. Because the relay is under the
hood, the fuse and its mounting gets very corroded, very
easily. Remove the fuse, and clean all the contacts
thoroughly. If there is no power here, trace the wire back
to the key switch to find the break.
Testing the system
If you
have good power on both sides of the fuse on the OD relay,
the next check is made under the vehicle. At the back of the
transmission is the governor. This is a cylinder shaped
device that is driven by the speedometer gear with ONE wire
coming out of it. Inside the governor are weights that spin
with the driveshaft. When they reach the magic speed of 28
mph, the wire going into the governor is grounded. The full
circuit is that simple!
For
some reason the insulation on wire at the governor is always
made from the same cloth used since the 1930s. This wire
always seems to have a frayed spot. With the ignition key
turned on, jump the wire to ground.
(There could also be a wire connector between the governor
and the OD harness. Pull it apart and ground the wire that
was going to the governor). However you ground the governor
wire, you should then hear a click from the relay on the
firewall.
Power
comes from the fuse through the relay, which is then
activated whenever it is grounded.
Power from the relay to the governor does pass through the
kick down switch. If there is no relay click when grounding
the governor, check for 12 volts at the wire and trace it
back to the kick down switch and then back to the relay to
find the open circuit.
If you
have 12 volts at the governor and you hear a relay click
when you ground the governor, then the relay should be
sending power down to the solenoid. (the steel can on the
side of the trans) As soon as the solenoid gets power, it
too should click. (the solenoid is trying to push its
plunger shaft into the trans) If the solenoid does not
click, check to see that it is receiving 12 volts of power
directly from the relay.
If you
have determined that 12 volt power is being sent to the
solenoid from the relay, the solenoid can be tested by
providing it with 12 volts directly. There are two wires on
the solenoid. One wire activates the plunger and if it is
given power, it should engage. The other wire goes directly
to ground (part of the kick down circuit). Clip your 12 volt
power source to one of the wires, it should either activate
the solenoid or be completely grounded. (You have a 50%
chance of picking the correct wire)
90% of
the time all the electrical problems are nothing more than
loose and dirty connections. Remove the wire connections at
the relay and the kick down switch and ensure that they are
clean. I have had to sometimes spray the components with
WD-40 and polish the contacts. Occasionally you might have
to bend the tangs of the relay cover to gain access inside
the relay to file its contact points, but this is rare. When
the kick down switch was moved to the firewall it got away
from the road splash and all the dirt on the floor that
accumulates under the gas pedal and made them much more
reliable.
As an
FYI all the electrical components for ALL Borg Warner OD
transmissions are interchangeable. There are 6 & 12 volt
versions and it seems like everybody used their own
different types of wire connections, but once the
connections and voltages match up, most any component will
work in any system. (Some systems use a strange kick down
switch at the carburetor but the basic function is all the
same) So if you need a relay or solenoid you can use one
from a Chevrolet, Rambler or Studebaker etc. Firewall
mounted kick downs would generally have to come from a
FoMoCo vehicle 1963 and up.
Heavy
mechanical repair of the transmission itself is too in depth
for this article. As a quick test however, know that a
transmission that freewheels can generally be made
operational with an electrical repair. If the transmission
does not freewheel (This can even be checked with the
transmission out of the car) then it should be assumed that
the overdrive compartment was not filled with 90 wt oil and
the planetary gears are seized. It needs to go a
transmission specialist for a rebuild.
Maintenance
Maintenance
of a Borg-Warner overdrive is easy. The mot important thing
to know is that there are TWO places to add 90wt gear oil in
the transmission. There is the normal plug/hole in the side
of the transmission but ANOTHER plug/hole is in the tail
shaft area. Fill both to the bottom of the hole with normal
hypoid 90 wt gear oil as you would for any standard
transmission.
As
discussed above clean connections are essential for the
electrical system to function. I have a 1964 F-100 with 292
OD that I have used as a driver for over 25 years. In that
time I find that I have had to pull things apart about every
4-5 years to clean the wiring connections.
Lubing the cable
In a
functional system you will find that you rarely need to pull
the cable out while driving. You rarely ever need to lock
out the system. If you are restoring an OD equipped vehicle
you will most likely find that the cable has not been used
and is stuck. While they make replacements, the knob is not
correct for 1967-72 trucks and you can generally free up
yours with out much trouble.
The
cable must be removed completely to free it up. A big nut
behind the cable secures it to the bracket under the dash. A
1/2” nut & bolt secures the functional cable end to the lock
out lever on the transmission. The upper bolt on the
solenoid secures the bracket that holds the outer cable.
(Once unbolted, this sheet metal bracket is spread apart to
remove it from the cable) Unbolt everything and pull the
cable out through the firewall into the interior. By
twisting the outer cable you should be able to break loose
the inner cable enough to remove it. Use sandpaper to clean
all the corrosion from the inner cable. Then use a wire
wheel/brush to remove all the crud from the outer cable.
Next insert the inner cable back into the outer sheave and
spray the entire assembly with WD-40 or similar light oil.
The outer cable is composed of wire tightly twisted around
the inner cable. This design allows the oil to easily seep
inside. Work it a bit and then it should move very easily.
Adding overdrive
Overdrive can be added to any truck but you need to do it
completely.
A
complete overdrive transmission must be used. It is NOT
possible to add the overdrive component to an existing three
speed transmission. The main reason you cannot add the OD
parts to an existing 3 speed trans is the need for a
shaft/rod to pass from the gear box into the OD unit to
automatically lock out the OD freewheeling clutch whenever
it is shifted into reverse. Only gearboxes designed to be
fitted to an OD unit had this passage and internal linkage.
Potentially
any B-W overdrive transmission could be used. Excluding the
variations of using a Chevrolet or Mopar OD transmission I
will focus on Ford versions. There were only a few
variations made for all the years that OD was used. The
biggest and heaviest duty version is the T-85 with the R-11
overdrive. (The T-85 gearbox was also built as a straight 3
speed and all the gears from it will work in a T-85
overdrive case). When a case was destined to have an OD
added it was identified as a T-85N (see picture)
Borg-Warner
built OD units that used either 3 or 4 planetary gears. The
4 gear system is the strongest. It was identified as an R-11
unit. (see picture) These T-85/R-11 transmissions are strong
enough that they were used behind the most powerful FE
engines. Overdrive was offered behind the factory high
performance 390s and 406s in 1961-2 and the mighty 427 of
1963-4. After the 4 speed became available in 1962 request
for the OD transmission declined but it did function just as
intended by taming the very low rear end ratios that were
commonly installed in high-performance cars.
The
main difference between the transmission installed in a Ford
car and truck is the design of the tail shaft. Cars used a
one piece driveshaft with a slip yoke in the trans. Trucks
used a two piece shaft with a yoke bolted to the output
shaft. The OD gears and components are all identical. If you
have a broken truck trans and good OD gears in a passenger
car transmission a rebuilder can easily open up the OD unit
and swap the necessary components to make a car trans into a
truck version or vise versa.
The
next items needed to add an overdrive are all the
accessories:
1. The relay
mounted to the firewall
2. The kick down switch mounted to the firewall and
the accelerator linkage that activates it. (although
it is also possible to use an older under pedal type
switch)
3. The OD cable and dash bracket. (and a firewall
grommet that seals the hole)
4. The wiring harness. (without a harness the wiring
harness can be fabricated by connecting the
terminals and components as shown in the wiring
diagram) {see image}
While
it seems like it might be difficult to add or repair a
factory type Borg-Warner overdrive system, once you learn
how to use the system to its maximum potential and
versatility you will find it well worth the effort. |